v50 Steam/Premium information for editors
  • v50 information can now be added to pages in the main namespace. v0.47 information can still be found in the DF2014 namespace. See here for more details on the new versioning policy.
  • Use this page to report any issues related to the migration.
This notice may be cached—the current version can be found here.

Difference between revisions of "User talk:Waladil"

From Dwarf Fortress Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
Line 12: Line 12:
 
== [[Dwarf Fortress Wiki:Versions]] ==
 
== [[Dwarf Fortress Wiki:Versions]] ==
 
Based on your comments and input on the administration requests pages I thought you might be interested in this kind of discussion.  Please bring in your comments on this page and on it's talk page and let everyone know what you think.  Thanks! [[User:Mason11987|Mason11987]] 20:46, 28 February 2010 (UTC)
 
Based on your comments and input on the administration requests pages I thought you might be interested in this kind of discussion.  Please bring in your comments on this page and on it's talk page and let everyone know what you think.  Thanks! [[User:Mason11987|Mason11987]] 20:46, 28 February 2010 (UTC)
−
 
−
==[[40d:Challenges]]==
 
−
RL concerns and "accuracy" really have no relevance to or place in DF articles.  It's like arguing whether a pike should be better than a spear - it is in DF, and that's where we are, so end of discussion.  All good, readya later.--[[User:Albedo|Albedo]] 18:45, 24 March 2010 (UTC)
 
−
 
−
:You may want to check who you're upbraiding: When you undid my comment about the real slope of mountains, it was in fact a reply to somebody else's comment. You seem to be set on believing I'm in the wrong. However, when I took a moment to compare _your_ changes to _my_ comments, we are in fact in total and complete agreement. You changed a dome from being 20 wide and 20 tall to being 20 wide (10 in radius) and 10 tall (10 in radius again) which was pretty much my point. You deleted a total of four sentences, two of which were written by me. The other two weren't me.<br />All I wrote was "Actually, any mountain that went five feet up for every twenty feet across would be nearly impossible to climb. Try it sometime." My point was that if a mountain went up five feet (my personal approximation for a tile/z-level) every fifteen or twenty feet that would make it a very steep hill.<br />However, the person before me said "1 tile does '''NOT''' necessarily equal 1 Z-level; after all even the steepest mountains change a Z-level only every 3 or 4 tiles." Therefore, my rebuttal was centered around the fact that the steepest mountains would change approximately 5 feet per fifteen, making DF's steepest mountains approximately on par with our own.<br />The end result of all this is simple: Somebody made an incorrect comment, and I provided a rebuttal. In what appears to be a fit of self-righteous arrogance, you attributed a much larger quantity of writing to me than was accurate and managed to agree with me, then tell me how wrong I am. Moreover, if you had been spending time reading on the forums, you would understand that Toady does attempt to model DF on reality, even if it's sometimes off. For example, the funky crook symbol is actually supposed to represent a kilogram, and is being made accurate to that measurement in the next version.<br />However, if you think you know better than Toady, then be my guest. --[[User:Waladil|Waladil]] 03:11, 30 March 2010 (UTC) <br />P.S. Putting the "minor change" tick-mark on the box doesn't actually make it a minor change. That box is for things like spelling and grammar, not deleting a paragraph.
 
−
 
−
You may want to check who you're upbraiding
 
−
::When I "upbraid", you'll know it (trust me).  The phrase "all good" would have been a clue to most that this wasn't that.
 
−
The end result of all this is simple: Somebody made an incorrect comment, and <br />I provided a rebuttal.
 
−
:: And both were inappropriate, which is why both took the high dive.  It's not the content, but the format.  A DF wiki article page is not for "rebuttals", it's for facts relevant to DF. I was quite aware of what I deleted, and both were of a kind. (If I'd seen the other before your addition, it would have gone just as fast, all by itself.) --[[User:Albedo|Albedo]] 04:48, 30 March 2010 (UTC)
 

Latest revision as of 15:27, 30 January 2011

Welcome to this wiki! Dwarf Fortress rapidly becomes more complicated, and we're always glad to have new writers.
Since you should try to follow wiki standards, and you probably don't know ours yet, we've made a list of basic guidelines. Note that this is a template, not a customized message for you.

  • To tell us who you are when you talk, please sign your posts on discussion pages by typing --~~~~ after your posts. This can also be inserted with the Button sig756222.png button if JavaScript is enabled.
  • Don't put a question mark in the title of a page. Question marks mess things up, and your page will be moved to a different name.
  • When making comments on a talk page, use one more colon before each line in your comment than was used in the comment you reply to. In general, put exactly one empty line between comments by different users but do not use blank lines inside of a comment.
  • Avoid making many small edits to a page. Instead, try to make one large edit. This makes the history of the page a lot easier to read.
  • Don't edit the user page of another user. If you want to tell them something, add the comment to their talk page.
  • If you put a comment at the bottom of a talk page with section headers, you've probably put it in a section. Putting things in the wrong sections is confusing. You can create a section!
  • Generally, read and follow the rules. They're like a little constitution, except not boring! Really, read them.
"You have been processed! Go forth, now, and edit!" --Savok

Dwarf Fortress Wiki:Versions[edit]

Based on your comments and input on the administration requests pages I thought you might be interested in this kind of discussion. Please bring in your comments on this page and on it's talk page and let everyone know what you think. Thanks! Mason11987 20:46, 28 February 2010 (UTC)

Retrieved from "https://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php?title=User_talk:Waladil&oldid=135553"