Editing 40d Talk:Steel

The damage %age relative to iron of just about everything else (silver weapons, copper weapons, etc.) is listed in the respective article. Do we know it for steel (I've noticed it's missing for adamantine as well,) or how to find it?--[[User:Eurytus|Eurytus]] 9:51   2 April 2008 (EST)

:It is there, though it may not be in a standard location. --[[User:Savok|Savok]] 23:53, 2 April 2008 (EDT)

== Carbon required? ==

The math on this page seems to be slightly off.

One carbon (coke or charcoal) is needed to create pig iron, and one to combine iron and pig iron into steel. This assumes a magma smelter.

However, four smelting operations are involved: two to make iron, one to make pig iron, and one to make steel. So if you're using a non-magma smelter, wouldn't this mean four MORE fuel, for a total of six, rather than just four total?

In other words, is the fuel definitely used as a carbon source? I'm pretty sure this used to not be the case.
@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
 In other words, is the fuel definitely used as a carbon source? I'm pretty sure this used to not be the case.
-:Yeah, the production chain part is badly worded, and as far as I can tell is also wrong. When using a non-magma smelter, the coke/coal needed to make the pig iron and the final steel also counts as the fuel. I noticed this when making some plate early on for military dwarves, the normal smelter had chalk, charcoal, pig iron bar, iron bar for the final steel making. When I've got some time, I'll redo the production chain. [[User:Blackcat|Blackcat]] 06:08, 28 August 2008 (EDT)
-::Just tested pig iron and steel making ''again'' to double check. A normal smelter will use one iron bar, one flux and one charcoal to make pig iron. For steel it will use one iron bar, one pig iron bar, one flux and one charcoal. I've cleaned up this page, and I've also added minor notes to the [[smelting]] page. [[User:Blackcat|Blackcat]] 07:30, 28 August 2008 (EDT)
-== need coal? ==
-If I happen to have a magma smelter, would it still need coal for this and pig iron? [[User:Destor|Destor]] 19:30, 20 October 2008 (EDT)
-:Coal or charcoal, yes.  Steel is an iron-carbon alloy, and the carbon in it comes from the coal.  Pig iron is also an iron-carbon alloy, used as an intermediate product in the production of steel.--[[User:Maximus|Maximus]] 00:58, 21 October 2008 (EDT)
-== steel to iron? ==
-When the gobbos drop their steel stuff and I melt it down it gives me an iron bar instead of a steel one.
-is this normal, or is my data somehow messed with
-:(Unsigned comment by [[User:Klanz]])
-:Goblins don't have steel, they have iron.  Therefore you melt their stuff down and get iron. --[[User:Squirrelloid|Squirrelloid]] 01:10, 27 January 2009 (EST)